Cheap Grace - Bay Area Fellowship
Posted by Chris McKinny | Posted in Corpus Christi , Heresy , Ventings , Wow | Posted on 8:41 AM
12
Bay Area Fellowship is a a mega-church in Corpus Christi lead by Bill Cornelius. This Easter they are planning a "Ultimate Giveaway" in which they will be giving over 1 million dollars worth of prizes. This decision as you might suspect has caused quite a stir both from outside of the church (see the Corpus Christi Caller Times article on it here) and inside the church. Normally I try to stay out of stuff like this, but on this I cannot remain silent - Bay Area Fellowship has gone too far (not that this blog is going to change anything - but it makes me feel better). Below is a comment I left on BAF's blog - here is the blog post and my comment (I doubt it will make it onto the web page):
Responding to Criticism
March 30, 2010 - 8:41pm — bafadminIt's understandable to be upset when someone knocks the church you attend. Just remember, they are not knocking you, they are knocking me, and I'm okay with it. Most of the people who are criticizing our Easter plans are not the kind of people we are trying to reach, so no worries. Although it certainly is not my desire to anger people, as long as the unchurched are being reached in a God-honoring way, then just pray for God's best and stay above the fray (the negativity). I'm so proud of our people for being so generous, in giving all the prizes and bikes that will be given away this Easter! Free gifts draw people to malls and stores, so why not God's House? In fact, the Ultimate Free Gift is what Easter is all about! -Pastor Bil
MY COMMENT
Dear Bil Cornelius,
Have you ever read the following passage?
“In the temple he (Jesus) found those who were selling oxen and sheep and pigeons, and the money-changers sitting there. And making a whip of cords, he drove them all out of the temple, with the sheep and oxen. And he poured out the coins of the money-changers and overturned their tables. And he told those who sold the pigeons, “Take these things away; do not make my Father’s house a house of trade.”His disciples remembered that it was written, “Zeal for your house will consume me.””(John 2:14–17 ESV)
Since when did the church become a car-dealership offering promotional deals to potential buyers? Is the Gospel that ugly to you that you have to trick unbelievers into buying into it? The Messiah was not a used car-salesmen the Wisdom of God told people that they had to come and die to attain eternal life you tell them you can have a free car, just like they can have free eternal life. Are we reading the same bible? Eternal life is not free, heaven is not without cost - it costs you everything - convincing unbelievers and believers that heaven is like a million-dollar give-a-way is the same as damning them to hell. You call for a grace without strings attached just like winning the lotto - Jesus calls for obedience - the two could not be more polar opposites.
Since when did the celebration of the death and resurrection of the King of Kings become a carnival raffle?
Furthermore - your contention that those who criticize the "give-away" are just criticizing you is absolutely baseless. Are you serious? Do you not claim to be a church - the bride of Christ? Not only is your local church complicit in this, but the entirety of the worldwide church as well. You bear the reputation of the murdered, resurrected Life-giver and Obedience-demander and you say "I will bear the shame." You are greatly mistaken - Christ the grave conqueror bears the shame. Congratulations you have successfully nullified the grace of Christ and caused his name to reek to the lost and dying world that you were trying to reach.
Your decision to create your church into a mockery is an abomination on so many levels.
Did you even consider the fact that this give away will cause unrelenting covetousness among your church? Some will walk away with a car some with a goody bag - do you really think that they will be focused on your message, flawed as it may be? Perhaps you are on the wrong career path - I hear Oprah is retiring - maybe you can call NBC so that you can take over her show - after all she also runs a "A few of my favorite things" promotional give-away (at least she does not compare it to the death of the Suffering Servant). Since when did someone say that Jesus was beautiful because I won a Beemer?
I pray that you will repent and that your church members will see the complete lunacy in this and practice some discernment. May every believer be reminded of the slain, yet resurrected Lord this Passion Week and the high cost of our obedience to the worthy, sacrificed Passover Lamb.
Prayerfully Yours,
Chris McKinny

Wow Chris. You blow me away. I am so proud of you for standing up for our Lord and Savior. I love you and keep it up.
Well stated. Thanks for writing down what others are thinking. Cheap Grace that cost the Son of God his life, sounds like they are the opposite to me.
A couple of comments I read on the blog said something like - "people just don't get it isn't someone's soul worth more than a car"
the point is yes - it cost God his son and it cost you your independence - isn't that worth more than a car
Read an article about it and I was wondering how familiar you were with the church. Great, necessary post.
And I'm loving the blog in general. Keep it coming.
By the way, I got a few comments on the same issue coming soon. Your blog was useful in helping me articulate my thoughts.
God is doing amazing things in Bay Area and through Bil. I'm part of the choir and it's amazing to see God working through everyone and how this is going to draw people in. Bil told us yesterday at practice that if we get this excited a car, why not get this excited for Heaven? He's using it as a methaphor. Attend the service tomorrow. He's going to blow your mind.
Proud of you, Chris, keep hammer'n the Truth...love you, Mel
AMEN & AMEN!!! to you post. It is all about "getting" with those people. Choir member, "Anonymous", wrote "...if we get this excited about a car, why not get this excited for heaven?" Can you imagine comparing the excitement of selfish, crass materialism to that of standing before the Lamb of God in heaven? That's supposed to be a metaphor? Give me a break! Olstein said that we could have our best now...sounds like more of the same balony. 2 Timothy 4:3-4
Go tonight and be amazed. No joke.
www.livejournal.com/shelbyforward
Great Job Chris!! I too am very proud of you.
May God's Word continue to grow in you richly.
Laura C.
If I were not in Israel I would be at BAF hoping that my criticism was off-base. But I am not dissuaded that it is - people speak of being amazed and God working through extraordinary measures - does scripture no longer have authority? If a methodology of outreach causes the message of the Gospel to be changed it is a bad methodology. If a flashy method causes church members to covet (i.e. "man, she got a car and all I got was a laptop") it is a wicked practice - since when is it ok to tempt the sheep while trying to reach the goats? I challenge anyone to examine the message being proclaimed - the issue is not the gimmick in itself but the Holy message which it corrupts. People talk of it being a metaphor for heaven - they are exactly right - it is the perfect metaphor for a heaven of Cornelius' making - a heaven where people receive it for simply showing up. Does this passage sound like free salvation? Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life; whoever does not obey the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God remains on him. John 3:36.